Understanding the California FAIR Plan in 2024

13 June 2024
Checklist - Banner Image for Understanding the California FAIR Plan Blog

Finding homeowner’s insurance can be difficult for California residents. Many will need to turn to California’s high-risk pool, known as the FAIR Plan.

FAIR Plan coverage allows all California homeowners to have access to basic fire insurance protection. You can obtain a FAIR Plan as long as your difficulties in finding coverage aren’t the result of your own actions. Let’s review our comprehensive guide of the California FAIR Plan for August 2023.

Who owns the California FAIR Plan?

While many people believe the FAIR Plan is a government entity or state program, this is not the case. Taxpayers do not fund the program. The FAIR Plan is supported by all of the carriers who are licensed to do business in the state of California.

This arrangement spreads the risk between all the insurance carriers at once.

What does a California FAIR Plan policy cover in 2024?

The FAIR Plan covers property damage due to fire, lightning, smoke, or internal explosions. You can also purchase optional extended coverage for windstorms, hail, explosions, riots, aircraft, or vehicles, as well as for vandalism or malicious mischief. You can also get optional coverage for other structures, like storage sheds.

It does cover less than traditional homeowners’ insurance policies. For example, the FAIR Plan does not offer coverage for theft, falling objects, freezing, water damage, or personal liability.

It is important to pay close attention to what your specific coverage includes or excludes so you can stay prepared. You can sometimes make up the gaps with a Difference in Conditions or Comprehensive Premises Liability Policy.

What is a Difference in Conditions (DIC) and a Comprehensive Premises Liability (CPL) Policy?

A Difference in Conditions policy offers more coverage than a Comprehensive Premises Liability policy.

DIC covers liability, medical payments to others, theft, and water damage. This, along with the FAIR Plan, will give you as close to a traditional homeowner’s insurance product as you can get.

DIC policies are not available to all homeowners because they are based on the type of construction. If you have a manufactured home on private property, then you likely can’t get a DIC policy. You may also be unable to get a DIC policy if your roof is too old, or if you’ve had too many claims. It’s all about whether or not you present a level of risk that’s acceptable to DIC carriers.

If your home doesn’t qualify for DIC, a Comprehensive Premises Liability Policy may be an option. CPL policies cover trip and fall cases, as well as medical payments to others.

What Is the Process for Purchasing the California FAIR plan in 2024?

1. Complete the FAIR Plan Worksheet

First, we’ll ask you to complete a worksheet. This worksheet will verify the details of your home such as the year built, the square footage, and your finishes. Finishes are details like carpet vs. hardwood or marble vs. Formica.

We’ll also verify whether you live in the home, use it as a vacation home, or rent it out.

2. Make sure you know your replacement costs

Your broker then goes into the calculator and begins looking at replacement cost coverages. We want to be able to replace your home as it stands right now. If you have tile now, you’ll get tile when you replace the home.

Replacement costs can be about $250/per square foot, and it goes up from there based on your finishes.

If you have access to a contractor, you can reach out to them to find out what your home replacement costs will look like. Our software shows the nationwide average, and it won’t necessarily be the same as Nevada County. Getting numbers from a contractor can help ensure that you have enough replacement coverage.

3. Get photos of your home

We then enter all of your data and upload photos of all four sides of your home. The photos have to have a date stamp. You can send them as the homeowner, or your agent may be able to come out and take photos.

4. Get a quote from the FAIR plan

The FAIR Plan then goes through your application, and you’ll get a customized quote that will be good for 30 days.

5. Agree to the quote and make your first payment.

If you give the FAIR Plan the green light, they will take their payment either in full or as a first installment. If this is your first term with the California FAIR Plan you will have to pay them to bind the policy. If you have a mortgage impound account, the agent has to bill the mortgage company and they’ll need to pay as well, which means you’ll end up overpaying on that first installment. Yes, we know this doesn’t make any sense!

Once the FAIR Plan sees the overpayment, they will return the overage to the second payer, which will be your mortgage company. It will be up to you to get the payment back from the mortgage company should you choose to do so. Some people choose not to in order to stay a little bit ahead on their payments.

On renewal, the CA FAIR Plan can invoice either you or the mortgage company, so you won’t run into this issue. Unfortunately, they just can’t do it on your first term.

Is a California FAIR Plan Expensive?

Because the California FAIR Plan is a high-risk policy you should expect to pay more than you’d pay for a standard homeowner’s policy.

How do I pay for my California FAIR Plan?

You can make a payment online. If this is your first term with the CA FAIR plan, you’ll have to make a payment yourself to lock in the policy. As mentioned, if you have a mortgage impound account your agent can bill that account after your first payment.

You’ll receive all of your policy documents and billing documents directly from the CA FAIR Plan, so you’ll know exactly what you need to do and when you need to do it.

What requirements must I meet to qualify for California FAIR Plan insurance?

To qualify for the FAIR Plan, you may have to make some improvements to your home that will limit your damage risk. This could include removing dangerous trees, upgrading your electrical wiring, and making other changes as directed by your insurance company.

Remember, FAIR Plans are available to people who can’t find coverage “through no fault of their own.” This means if you fail to make the changes the FAIR Plan can still deny coverage. The good news is this: if you make the changes and have been insured by a FAIR Plan you may be able to switch back to a regular homeowner’s policy in the future.

If you have questions about the California FAIR Plan, reach out to one of our agents. We can help you shop for coverage for your home.

Proposals to the California FAIR Plan pending approval

Some of the proposals pending approval from the California Department of Insurance (CDI) are:

The FAIR Plan is also challenging an order from the CDI that requires it to offer a quasi-HO-3 policy, which is a more comprehensive homeowners insurance policy than the basic fire coverage that the FAIR Plan currently provides. The FAIR Plan argues that this order will lead to unnecessary rate increases for all policyholders and expand the role of the FAIR Plan beyond its intended purpose as a safety net for high-risk properties. The FAIR Plan has appealed a court decision that denied its request to halt the enforcement of the CDI’s order. It is important to note that insurance regulations and policies can change over time, so it is always a good idea to check with the California FAIR Plan Association or a licensed insurance agent to get the most up-to-date information on coverage options and requirements.

Stay up to date with us, let’s go over some of the recent changes to the California FAIR Plan:

  1. Increase in Coverage Limits: A couple of years ago the coverage limits for residential and commercial properties increased from $1.5 million to $3 million. This increase was made to keep up with the rising property values in California.
  2. Expanded Coverage for Wildfire Damage: In response to the devastating wildfires that have affected California in recent years, the FAIR Plan has expanded its coverage for wildfire damage. Policyholders can now get coverage for damage caused by wildfires, including smoke damage and damage from fire suppression efforts.
  3. New Online Payment System: The FAIR Plan has launched a new online payment system that allows policyholders to pay their premiums online. This change was made to make it easier for policyholders to make payments and to improve the overall customer experience.


Lisa Newman - Inszone Insurance Senior Personal Insurance Specialist

Lisa Newman

Senior Personal Insurance Specialist

Lisa Newman is a Senior Personal Insurance Specialist at Inszone Insurance Services, joining Inszone in July 2021 after the merger with Interstate Benefits & Casualty Insurance Services. Lisa began her career in 2006 when she was hired as the agency’s bookkeeper and in 2009, she became a licensed agent specializing in home and auto.

Lisa’s bookkeeping skills naturally transferred her into the policy service part of being an agent. Communication, listening, and attention to detail are her keys to success, and the experience she received has made all the difference to her as she continues to serve her customers as well as her community at large.

Lisa has been a resident of Nevada County since 1989 and has been involved in many community groups. Currently she is the co-founder of the Newman Memorial Foundation which was founded after the loss of her two sons, Ryan and Brett. The Newman Foundation provides scholarships to assist young adults in her community to defray the costs of their first year in college.

On her off time, she enjoys spending time with her grandson, Finn, being a homemaker, serving at her church, making Sunday dinner, crafting, and reading.

Change Contrast
Change Font Size
Reset to Default Settings
Close the Toolbar